The Fight For Intellectual Honesty

There will be no phone calls and I am not expecting an email. I still, for no apparent reason, believe that our elected representatives will rise above the pettiness of partisan politics and do their jobs.  It is, in part, what makes me a Democrat, this faith that our government of the people will always come through in the end.  The end may be far, far away and we may be forced to take the long way to get there, but I believe, I honestly believe, that we, as a country, will always make it to the finish line.

Otherwise, if we are just another banana republic, I’m going to trade up to a place with better weather.

This blog has a long history of calling out members of both political parties. We have witnessed politicians attempt to occupy both sides of the debate even after they had made their choices.  In 2009 and 2010 it was particularly easy to skewer Representatives Marcia Fudge and Dennis Kucinich and Senator Sherrod Brown.  After all, the Democrats were the only ones doing anything.  But then the 2010 elections shifted the balance of power.  John Boehner has starred in many of these posts, first in highlighting the opportunities he had as he became the Speaker of the House and later as we dealt with the reality of him being the Speaker of the HousePaul Ryan, VP candidate and prince of unworkable budgets, has also appeared a time or two on these pages.

It is not enough to be for something or against something. That may be OK if we are just a bunch of guys discussing football over a couple of beers.  But if you are in Congress it is your job to solve problems.  And if you don’t like the current system, it is up to you to come up with an alternative.

I bumped into a representative from Congressman David Joyce’s office.  I introduced myself as a health insurance agent and asked a simple question: “If the Republicans gain control of both the House and the Senate in November, will Congressman Joyce support the repeal of the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act (PPACA) when it comes up for a vote in January?”  Without a moment’s hesitation she said “YES”.  She answered so quickly, so unthinkingly, that I decided to ask the question again.  The answer was still a resounding “YES”.

“OK”, I continued, “what do I tell my clients the next day”?

She promised to have someone from the Congressman’s legislative committee contact me. I made sure that she understood the question and provided her with a business card.  And unless this blog is brought to their attention, there is virtually no chance that I will get a substantive answer to that question.  That is a huge problem.

Please don’t be confused. The PPACA will not be repealed.  Neither the Democrats nor the Republicans would want that, especially the elected Republicans.  As long as the PPACA remains the law of the land, the Republicans have an issue to inflame their base and fill their coffers.  AND, they don’t have responsibility for anything.  Repeal the law and the Republicans would own healthcare and 20% of the economy.  It is a lose / lose proposition.  The law won’t be repealed.  The filibuster in the Senate will keep both parties safe.  The President will never be force to veto a repeal.

Don’t believe me? I visited the websites of several members of the Ohio Republican Congressional Delegation.  Their sections on healthcare were missing in details, or in the case of John Boehner, missing entirely.  David Joyce, two years in Congress, is just happy to have voted for repeal.  He likes tort reform, but what Republican doesn’t?  Jim Renacci is an even bigger fan of tort reform, and thinks that the savings from frivolous law suits would fund most of the cost of improving our system.  A couple of downstate Republicans, Mike Turner and Steve Stivers haven’t bothered to update their healthcare pages for 9 months or more.  Don’t look for solutions on any of these pages.  Don’t look for meaningful alternatives.  It is easy to be against something.  It is really hard to make something work.

I am not expecting a phone call from the Congressman’s office. Why should they call?  Nothing they have to say would change anything.  I’ve already cast my vote.  And in the two years he has been in office, he has cast his votes to repeal the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act.  The House will waste even more time in January and the Senate may be forced to waste time in April, while wars are waged in the Middle East and Ebola spreads unchecked.

The absence of intellectual honesty threatens the future of our country. I still believe that our elected officials will one day work together to solve our country’s problems.  Of course, I could be just lying to myself



phone for sale


This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to The Fight For Intellectual Honesty

  1. […] have been watching someone else run out the clock. Last month I wrote about my conversation with a member or Congressman Joyce’s […]

  2. […] wealth, power, and almost unlimited resources.  What we lack, what we desperately need, is more intellectual honesty.  There is no reason to believe that that is going to change anytime […]

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Time limit is exhausted. Please reload CAPTCHA.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.