The One Year Anniversary of Health Insurance Issues With Dave, and yes, Anthony Weiner Still Hates Me

Today marks the first anniversary of this blog. Please allow me to again thank Brad Kleinman and David Toth of WorkSmart for teaching a class on eMarketing and social networking for the Beachwood Chamber of Commerce last January. Their motivation and the wonderful feedback I receive from you, my readers, keep me excited about producing these posts.

On September 21, 2009 I posted an article entitled Anthony Weiner Hates Me. Mr. Weiner is a Congressman from New York City who is entirely convinced that insurance companies are an unnecessary drain on our system. He has preached from the alter of single payer government run health plans on the Rachel Maddow Show, Countdown with Keith Olbermann and the Huffington Post. Mr. Weiner even shows up on the Sunday morning shows every now and then. His extreme views make for good television. Congressman Anthony Weiner was on the Daily Show with Jon Stewart last night.

Anthony Weiner and Jon Stewart have been friends for a long time. How long? Half the interview was dedicated to the threat of exposing incriminating photos from the 1980’s each still had in his possession. That was the interesting part of the interview. The rest? Nothing terribly new.

Realizing that he didn’t have a lot of time, Mr. Weiner spoke in bullet points.
• Medicare is a single-payer system that works.
• We should extend Medicare to people 55 and older. Why start at age 65?
• We should extend Medicare as an option to recent college graduates who are no longer covered by their parents’ policies.
• We should extend Medicare as an option to people who have lost their jobs.
• Medicare has a 1% overhead vs. the insurance companies at over 30%
• We should cap what insurance companies can charge.

Somewhere in this tangle of talking points, Mr. Weiner stopped to take a breath. And here is where the friendship, or the pictures from the 80’s, paid off. Jon Stewart didn’t challenge any of his friend’s assumptions. He allowed this fact-free, totally unsupportable, completely unrealistic presentation to proceed. Jon Stewart, someone unafraid to confront, intellectually, Jim Cramer and Keith Olbermann, devolved into the Memphis Grizzlies defense and watched LeBron James drive to the hoop. Mind you, I wasn’t looking for a hard foul (continuing the basketball metaphor), but I would have appreciated an attempt to protect the basket, or truth.

This blog has dealt with the good and bad of Medicare numerous times. I’m not sure you have the patience to reread much of that. It is still vitally important to note that Medicare does serve a purpose. Medicare is an important part of our current mish-mosh of payers. And of course, anytime the government is involved in writing checks, a lot of what services are, or are not, available are determined by Washington. But Medicare was never designed to pay all the costs of health care for anyone.

Let’s talk about the specifics of Medicare. It wouldn’t be fair, easy but not fair, for me to cherry-pick this. So this is what Medicare really does and doesn’t cover.

PREMIUM – $110.50 per month, assuming you make less than $85,000 per year.


Semiprivate room and board, general nursing, and miscellaneous services and supplies:
First 60 days – You pay $1,068
61st day through 90th – You pay $267 per day
91st day and after while using
Your 60 lifetime reserve days – You pay $534 per day

Skilled Nursing Facility Care
You must meet Medicare’s requirements, including having been in a hospital for at least three days and entered a Medicare-approved facility within 30 days after leaving the hospital.
First 20 days – You pay $0
21st day through 100th day – You pay $133.50 per day
101st day and after – YOU PAY EVERYTHING

First three pints – You pay everything
Additional amounts – You pay $0

Hospice Medicare pays for all with very limited coinsurance
For outpatient drugs and inpatient respite care


Medical Expenses – In and out of the hospital and outpatient treatment such as physician’s services, inpatient and outpatient medical and surgical services and supplies, physical and speech therapy, diagnostic tests and durable medical equipment,

First $135 of Medicare approved amounts – You pay $135
Remainder of Medicare approved amounts – You pay 20%

Part B Excess Charges, the amount above
Medicare approved amounts YOU PAY EVERYTHING

First three pints You pay everything
Next $135 of Medicare approved amounts – You Pay $135
Remainder of Medicare approved amounts – You pay 20%

Clinical Laboratory Services – You pay $0

Home Health Care
Medicare approved services
Medically necessary skilled care
Services and medical supplies – You pay $0
Durable medical equipment
First $135 of Medicare approved amounts – You pay $135
Remainder of Medicare approved amounts – You pay 20%


Sorry, there was no way easy way to explain this policy. Above are the basics, the shell. What does this really mean?
1. There is no prescription coverage.
2. There are huge gaps as to what is and isn’t adequately covered.
3. People who rely strictly on Medicare are woefully underinsured.

How underinsured? A study released today at the fifth annual
Community Oncology Conference in Scottsdale, Arizona clearly states that “Medicare covers only 56% of the actual costs of administering chemotherapy and providing related infusion room services to seniors with cancer”. We have already discussed how Medicare has reduced the payments to medical providers. According to the report, Mr. Weiner’s favorite single payer has reduced the payments for cancer drug infusion room services by over 25% since 2004. Are the doctors silently bearing these reductions? Are you and I paying more for these and other services as the cost for care is shifted, more each day, to those of us with private insurance?

There were lots of other holes in Congressman Weiner’s presentation. I appreciated that he has now reduced this imaginary overhead expense for Medicare from the unlikely 4% that he had claimed last summer to the impossible 1% of last night. But I know that this is already too long.

There was one saving grace to Congressman Anthony Weiner’s appearance on the Daily Show. When asking Mr. Weiner about his Mayoral ambitions, he wondered aloud whether Michael Bloomberg could have been defeated. Without hesitation Mr. Weiner opined “I would beat him like a rented mule”. See, I’m not the only person Anthony Weiner hates.


This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

6 Responses to The One Year Anniversary of Health Insurance Issues With Dave, and yes, Anthony Weiner Still Hates Me

  1. Donna says:

    Hi Dave:

    Congratulations on your first year of blogging and thanks so much for the Woody Allen CD. It took my mind off the fact that I was driving home in a snowstorm and it also gave my husband and I some good laughs as we ate dinner last night.

    I'm enjoying both of your blogs immensely and have appreciated our intellectual exchanges.

    Now, as for Mr. Weiner, I do think just using Medicare is a grossly oversimplified solution for all the reasons you name. My dad is on Medicare and has the Medigap insurance and I've never heard him complain about his health care bills and, like our friend Mr. Woody Allen, he can be a bit neurotic about his health and is no stranger to the doctor's office.

    But he hasn't had to deal with anything catastrophic – like long-term hospitalization. Perhaps not everyone is in the same boat as him.

    Sometimes it's hard to know what to think about this exactly. You've got seniors like my dad, who seem to be perfectly happy with his health coverage and who are not being driven to the poorhouse with his copays and you've got the proverbial senior choosing between drugs and food.

    Perhaps – even if you try to level the playing field – there are always going to be the haves and have-nots of this world.

  2. Dave Cunix says:

    Medicare, which is not self-sufficient and is underpaying the medical providers, costs $110.50 per month. A comprehensive Medicare Supplement, such as plan C from Anthem, is $201.53 per month for a 70 year old. Medicare Part D (Rx) is another $47 per month. So a 70 year old is paying $359.03 per month to be oblivious about the real cost of health care. What would it cost to really cover a senior's actual health cost? G-d only knows. What would it cost to provide this level of care to everyone? That is the question we should be asking. That and do we want to and are we willing to pay the cost!

  3. Brad Kleinman says:


    Thanks for the shot out!


  4. Lie To Me | says:

    […] Medicare was never designed to cover 100% of a senior citizen’s hospital or doctors’ bills. The first anniversary post of this blog included a complete breakdown of what Medicare does and doesn’t […]

  5. Some Russian guy plagarizing my blogs! says:

    […] was never designed to cover 100% of a senior citizen’s hospital or doctors’ bills. The first anniversary post of this blog included a complete breakdown of what Medicare does and doesn’t […]

  6. […] first detailed explanation of what was and wasn’t paid by Medicare can be found in this post from February 2010.  The Part A Deductible in 2010 was $1,068.  In 2019 it is $1,364, an increase of 28%.  The […]

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Time limit is exhausted. Please reload CAPTCHA.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.